Warning: file_put_contents(/opt/frankenphp/design.onmedianet.com/storage/proxy/cache/fef6ceed4f121b90ceadea850f9383ca.html): Failed to open stream: No space left on device in /opt/frankenphp/design.onmedianet.com/app/src/Arsae/CacheManager.php on line 36

Warning: http_response_code(): Cannot set response code - headers already sent (output started at /opt/frankenphp/design.onmedianet.com/app/src/Arsae/CacheManager.php:36) in /opt/frankenphp/design.onmedianet.com/app/src/Models/Response.php on line 17

Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /opt/frankenphp/design.onmedianet.com/app/src/Arsae/CacheManager.php:36) in /opt/frankenphp/design.onmedianet.com/app/src/Models/Response.php on line 20
The Party Politics of Englishness - Andrew Mycock, Richard Hayton, 2014
Skip to main content
Scheduled maintenance on Friday, 10th October and on Monday, 13th October. See what this means for you
Intended for healthcare professionals
Skip to main content
Restricted access
Research article
First published online October 4, 2012

The Party Politics of Englishness

Abstract

Research Highlights and Abstract
provides one of the first assessments of how British multi-national and English political parties have responded to existing and emergent identity tensions in England whilst continuing to defend the concept of the post-devolution British union-state.
extends debates about multi-level party political systems in multi-national states which have typically focused on Scotland, Wales and, to a lesser extent, Northern Ireland.
considers the potential that debates about English national identity could morph into a party politics of Englishness.
assesses the potential for nascent English nationalism to encourage divergent party political responses to questions of English governance, citizenship and nation identity.
This article assesses how the main British multi-national parties, whilst retaining an attachment of one form or another to the concept of the Union-state, have responded to existing and emergent identity tensions. Through examination of Labour, the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats, with brief discussion of the BNP, UKIP and the English Democrats, it will consider the impact of devolution and the threat of separatist nationalism on party approaches and policy choices concerning English identity construction and governance. It will also explore the extent to which devolution has compromised the ability of UK politicians to ‘speak of Britain’ (they rarely use the term UK) and the four composite nations. By comparing and contrasting the narratives articulated by parties at different levels of governance it will ask whether a nascent ‘party politics of Englishness’ has emerged which can accommodate these challenges.

Get full access to this article

View all access and purchase options for this article.

Bibliography

Aughey A. (2007) The Politics of Englishness (Manchester: Manchester University Press).
Aughey A. (2008) ‘A cloud no bigger than a man's hand’, Parliamentary Brief, 14 July. Available online at: http://www.parliamentarybrief.com/2008/07/a-cloud-no-bigger-than-a-mans-hand#all.
Aughey A. (2010) ‘Review: James Mitchell, devolution in the UK’, Parliamentary Affairs, 63:1, 212–217.
Aughey A. (2010) ‘Anxiety and injustice: The anatomy of contemporary English nationalism’, Nations and Nationalism, 16:3, 506–524.
Bartlett J., Littler M. (2011) Inside the EDL: Populist Politics in the Digital Age (London: Demos).
BBC (2000) ‘English Nationalism “threat to the UK”’. Available online at: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/596703.stm.
BBC (2011a) ‘Harri Lloyd Davies urges Welsh Conservative breakaway’. Available online at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-politics-12297591.
BBC (2011b) ‘Public spending formula “unfair to England and Wales”’. Available online at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-politics-12216346.
Baker K. (1998) ‘Speaking for England’, The Spectator, 1 August, 14–15.
Benn H. (2012) ‘Devolution is unfinished business we should put our trust in the English people’, Daily Telegraph, 22 April. Available online at: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/9219464/Devolution-is-unfinished-business-we-should-put-our-trust-in-the-English-people-says-Labours-Hilary-Benn.html.
Blunkett D. (2010) The Future of the United Kingdom—A Personal Perspective (Sheffield: University of Sheffield). Cambrian Society Lecture.
Bodden T. (2002) ‘Top Tory wants to change party name’, The Daily Post, 11 June. Available online at: http://www.dailypost.co.uk/news/north-wales-news/2002/06/11/top-tory-wants-to-change-party-name-55578-11942529/.
Bogdanor V. (2009) ‘The West Lothian question’, Parliamentary Affairs, 63:2, 156–172.
Bradbury J., Andrews R. (2010) ‘State devolution and national identity: Continuity and change in the politics of Welshness and Britishness in wales’, Parliamentary Affairs, 63:2, 229–249.
British National Party (2010) Democracy, Freedom, Culture and Identity: British National Party General Election Manifesto. Available online at: http://communications.bnp.org.uk/ge2010manifesto.pdf.
Brown M. (2010) ‘Nick Clegg's balancing act as hung parliament looms', Daily Telegraph, 10 April. Available online at: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/election-2010/7571076/General-Election-2010-Nick-Cleggs-balancing-act-as-hung-parliament-looms.html.
Cable V. (2005) Multiple Identities: Living with the New Politics of Identity (London: Demos).
Carswell D. (2009) ‘What England means to me’. Available online at: http://whatenglandmeanstome.co.uk/essay/douglas-carswell/.
Clegg N. (2009) ‘Liberal Democrat leader to debate Britishness in wake of Mosque protests’, Press Release, 17 September. Available online at: http://www.libdems.org.uk/press_releases_detail.aspx?title=Liberal_Democrat_Leader_to_debate_%E2%80%98Britishness%E2%80%99_in_wake_of_Mosque_protests&pPK=e8ae3647-3579-4ca7-976e-1713942fda32.
Condor S. (2010) ‘Devolution and national identity: The rules of English (dis)engagement’, Nations and Nationalism, 16:3, 525–543.
Conservative Party (2008) Answering the Question: Devolution, The West Lothian Question and the Future of the Union (London: Conservative Party).
Cruddas J. (2009) ‘Labour has misunderstood Britain: Time to start afresh’, The Guardian, 18 March. Available online at: http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2009/mar/18/labour-jon-cruddas.
Cruddas J. (2010) ‘Time for a truly English Labour Party’, New Statesman, 29 July. Available online at: http://www.newstatesman.com/uk-politics/2010/08/labour-party-english-england.
Cruddas J. (2011a) ‘John Tressell, the ragged trousered philanthropist’, Liverpool John Moores University Roscoe Lecture, 4 April. Available for downloading [spoken word] at: http://www.ljmu.ac.uk/roscoe/97603.htm.
Cruddas J. (2011b) Attlee, the ILP and the Romantic Tradition (Oxford: University of Oxford). The Clement Attlee Memorial Lecture.
Davis D. (2001) ‘Equality for the English’, Conservative Way Forward. Available online at: http://toque.co.uk/david-davis-equality-english.
Denham J. (2010) ‘How does Labour speak to England?’, Speech to the Fabian Society. Available online at: http://www.fabians.org.uk/events/speeches/how-does-labour-speak-to-england.
Denham J. (2012) ‘The rise of English pride’, Institute for Public Policy Research. Available online at: http://www.ippr.org/articles/56/8585/the-rise-of-english-pride.
Deschouwer K. (2003) ‘Political parties in multi-layered systems’, European Urban and Regional Studies, 10:213–226.
English R. (2011) Is There An English Nationalism? (London: Institute for Public Policy Research).
English Democrats [EDP] (2010) Manifesto of the English Democrats: Putting England First. Available online at: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/shared/bsp/hi/pdfs/EDP_uk_manifesto.pdf.
Facey P. (2012) ‘Speaking up for Englishness’. Available online at: http://unlockdemocracy.org.uk/blog/entry/speaking-up-for-englishness#.T9HkbZB0ZM0.twitter.
Farage N. (2011) ‘Speech at the UKIP party conference’, Eastbourne, 9 September. Available online (in video format) at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b014k6nb.
Field F. (2008) ‘The strange death of Labour England? Revisiting Bagehot's English Constitution’, The Chancellor's Lecture at University of Hertfordshire, 3 June.
Field F. (2011) ‘It's time for us to be confident in our Englishness', Liverpool Echo, 25 June, 11.
Ford R., Goodwin M., Cutts D. (2011) ‘Strategic Eurosceptics and polite xenophobes: Support for the United Kingdom Independence Party (UKIP) in the 2009 European Parliament elections’, European Journal of Political Research, 51:2, 204–234.
Foulkes G. (2011) ‘An English parliament in a federal UK’, Labour Hame, 14 June. Available online at: http://www.labourhame.com/archives/430#more-430.
Fraser M. (2011) ‘We don't need new captain of this sinking ship—we need a new ship’, The Scotsman, 5 September. Available online at: http://www.scotsman.com/news/politics/we-don-t-need-new-captain-of-this-sinking-ship-we-need-a-new-ship-1-1828107.
Glasman M. (2010) ‘England, my England’, Prospect, 175, 29.
Glasman M., Rutherford J., Stears M., White S. (eds) (2011) The Labour tradition and the politics of paradox. Available online at: http://www.soundings.org.uk.
Goodwin M., Evans J. (2012) From Voting to Violence? Far-Right Extremism in Britain (London: Searchlight Educational Trust).
Groves J. (2011) ‘A deeply divided kingdom: Scots each get $1,600 more state cash a year spent on them than the English’, Daily Mail, 30 August. Available online at: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2031543/UK-government-spending-Scots-1-600-year-spent-English.html#ixzz1ZN5Yio8V.
Hansard (2009) ‘Oral Answers to Questions: Culture, Media and Sport’, Column 1, 20 April. Available online at: http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200809/cmhansrd/cm090420/debtext/90420-0001.htm.
Hansard (2011) ‘Written Ministerial Statements—West Lothian Commission’, Column 27WS, 8 September. Available online at: http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201011/cmhansrd/cm110908/wmstext/110908m0001.htm.
Hayton R. (2010) ‘Towards the mainstream? UKIP and the 2009 elections to the European Parliament’, Politics, 30:1, 26–35.
Hayton R. (2012) Reconstructing Conservatism? The Conservative Party in Opposition, 1997–2010 (Manchester: Manchester University Press).
Hayton R., English R., Kenny M. (2009) ‘Englishness in contemporary British Politics’, Political Quarterly, 78:1, 122–135.
Hazell R. (2006) ‘The English question’, Publius: The Journal of Federalism, 36:1, 37–56.
Hodges D. (2010) ‘Stand by for English Ed’, Tribune, 7 November. Available online at: http://www.tribunemagazine.co.uk/2010/11/stand-by-for-english-ed/.
Holmes A. (2007) ‘Devolution, coalitions and the Liberal Democrats: Necessary evil or progressive politics?’, Parliamentary Affairs, 60:2, 527–547.
Hopkin J., Bradbury J. (2006) ‘British statewide parties and multi-level politics’, Publius: The Journal of Federalism, 36:1, 135–152.
Huhne C. (2009) ‘Raise the flag for a day off on St George's day’, Chris Huhne's Website, 17 April. Available online at: http://www.chrishuhne.org.uk/date/2009/04/page/2.
Jackson P. (2011) The EDL: Britain's ‘New Far Right’ Social Movement (Northampton: RNM Publications).
Johnson N. (2001) ‘Taking stock of constitutional reform’, Government and Opposition, 36:3, 331–354.
Jones O. (2012) ‘The incoherence of Englishness, and why Ed Miliband's England is a lost country’, The Independent, 8 June. Available online at: http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/commentators/owen-jones-the-incoherence-of-englishness-and-why-ed-milibands-england-is-a-lost-country-7827757.html.
Katz R. S. (2006) ‘Party in democratic theory’, in Katz R. S., Crotty W. (eds), Handbook of Party Politics (London: Sage, 34–46.
Kelly R., Byrne L. (2007) A Common Place (London: Fabian Society).
Kennedy C. (1999) Lecture to the Scottish Council Foundation, 30 June. Available online at: http://toque.co.uk/charles-kennedy-lecture-scottish-council-foundation.
Kennedy C. (2005) Speech to Liberal Democrats Annual Conference, Blackpool, 22 September. Available online at: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/4271902.stm.
Kenny M., Lodge G. (2009) ‘More than one English question’, in Perryman M. (ed.), Breaking up Britain: Four Nations after A Union (London: Lawrence and Wishart, 222–239.
Labour Party (2010) The Labour Party Manifesto: A Future Fair for All. Available online at: http://www.labour.org.uk/labours-manifesto-for-a-future-fair-for-all.
Laffin M., Shaw E. (2007) ‘British devolution and the Labour Party: How a national party adapts to devolution’, British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 9:1, 55–72.
Lee S. (2006) ‘Gordon Brown and the British way’, Political Quarterly, 77:3, 369–378.
Lee S. (2010) ‘Cameron scotched’, Parliamentary Brief, 19 May. Available online at: http://www.parliamentarybrief.com/2010/05/cameron-scotched.
Leith M. (2010) ‘Governance and identity in a devolved Scotland’, Parliamentary Affairs, 63:2, 286–301.
Liberal Democrats (2007) For the People, By the People: Policy Paper 83 (London: Liberal Democrats).
Liberal Democrats (2009) ‘Policy motion: The future of devolution—carried’. Annual Party Conference, Bournemouth, 20 September. Available online at: http://www.libdems.org.uk/policy_motions_detail.aspx?title=Policy_Motion%3A_The_Future_of_Devolution_-_carried&pPK=4817402c-20b5-4298-96de-46c3b918f310.
Liberal Democrats (2010) Facing the Future: Consultation Paper 101 (London: Liberal Democrats).
Liberal Democrats (2011) Facing the Future: Consultation Paper 100 (London: Liberal Democrats).
Livingstone T. (2008) ‘Clegg calls for talks on “unbalanced” Britain’, Western Mail, 11 February. Available online at: http://www.walesonline.co.uk/news/wales-news/2008/02/11/clegg-calls-for-talks-on-unbalanced-britain-91466-20460058/.
Lynch P. (1998) ‘Third party politics in a four-party system: The Liberal Democrats in Scotland’, Scottish Affairs, 22:16–32.
Martin I. (2012) ‘Ed Miliband cannot answer the English question’, Daily Telegraph, 8 June. Available online at: http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/iainmartin1/100163573/ed-miliband-cannot-deal-properly-with-the-english-question/.
McCartney K. (2011) ‘What England means to me’. Available online at: http://whatenglandmeanstome.co.uk/essay/karl-mccartney/.
McLean I., Schumuecker K., Lodge G. (2008) Fair Shares? Barnett and the Politics of Public Expenditure (London: IPPR).
Miliband D. (2010) ‘Labour needs to reconnect with England’, New Statesman, 1 July. Available online at: http://www.newstatesman.com/uk-politics/2010/07/lost-english-england-labour.
Miliband E. (2012) ‘Ed Miliband's speech on Englishness': Full transcript. Available online at: http://www.newstatesman.com/blogs/politics/2012/06/full-transcript-ed-milibands-speech-englishness.
Mitchell J. (2009) Devolution in the UK (Manchester: Manchester University Press).
Moon D., Bratberg O. (2010) ‘Conceptualising the multi-level party: Two complementary approaches’, Politics, 30:1, 52–60.
Mycock A. (2010) ‘New Labour and the English questions’, Open Democracy, 16 September. Available online at: http://www.opendemocracy.net/ourkingdom/andy-mycock/new-labour-and-english-questions.
Mycock A. (2011) ‘David Cameron must be careful about conflating Britain and England’, The Guardian, 6 February. Available online at: http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/feb/06/david-cameron-uk-devolution-citizenship.
Nuttall P. (2011) A Union for the Future: A Policy Proposal by Paul Nuttall MEP (London: United Kingdom Independence Party).
Ormston R. (2012) The English Question: How Is England Responding to Devolution? (London: NatCen).
Painter A. (2011) ‘Time for an optimistic Englishness’, Soundings, 49:6–17.
Redwood J. (2007) ‘Devolved Parliaments’. Available online at: http://www.johnredwoodsdiary.com/2007/01/04/devolved-parliaments/.
Riddell M. (2011) ‘Way to Blue’, Fabian Review, 123:2, 7–9.
Rooksby E. (2011) ‘Don't underestimate toxic blue Labour’, The Guardian, 21 May. Available online at: http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/may/21/blue-labour-lord-glasman-conservative-socialism.
Sandbrook D. (2011) ‘Family, faith and flag’, New Statesman, 7 April. Available online at: http://www.newstatesman.com/society/2011/04/labour-party-english-england.
Sylvester R. (2011) ‘Next Election is ours, says the patriotic voice of “blue Labour”’, The Times, 14 May.
Tomaney J. (1999) ‘New Labour and the English question’, Political Quarterly, 70:1, 75–82.
Trench A. (2011) ‘UKIP digs itself into another hole over an English parliament’, Devolution Matters, 11 September. Available online at: http://devolutionmatters.wordpress.com/2011/09/11/ukip-dig-themselves-into-another-hole/.
UKIP (2010a) Restoring Britishness: A Cultural Policy for an Independent Britain. Available online at: http://www.castles99.ukprint.com/UKIP/Britishness.pdf.
UKIP (2006) Fair Representation for all Britons—UKIP's Answer to the West Lothian Question. Available online at: http://www.stuartagnewmep.co.uk/stuartagnew/pdf/westlothianquestion.pdf.
UKIP (2010b) ‘UKIP calls for St George's Day holiday’. Available online at: http://www.ukip.org/content/latest-news/1558-ukip-call-for-st-georges-day-holiday.
Wellings B. (2012) English Nationalism and Euroscepticism: Losing the Peace (Oxford: Peter Lang).
Wyn-Jones R., Lodge G., Henderson A., Wincott D. (2012) The Dog That Finally Barked: England As An Emerging Political Community (London: Institute for Public Policy Research).