Jump to content

Adaptations of Manon Lescaut

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Black and white photograph of several people in eighteenth-century garb arranged on a stage. Near the centre, a man is singing with an arm outstretched toward a seated woman in an elegant dress.
1957 performance of Giacomo Puccini's 1893 opera Manon Lescaut

The French novel Manon Lescaut (1731) by Antoine François Prévost has been adapted many times into stage plays, ballets, operas, and films. Manon Lescaut tells a tragic love story about a nobleman (known only as the Chevalier des Grieux) and a common woman (Manon Lescaut). Their decision to live together without marrying is the start of a moral decline that also leads to gambling, fraud, theft, murder, and Manon's death as a deportee in New Orleans.

The first adaptation was a theatrical comedy in 1772. Early theatrical and operatic adaptations were not particularly successful, but in the nineteenth century, several major operas were produced. The most renowned adaptations of Manon Lescaut are the operas by Daniel Auber (1856), Jules Massenet (1884), and Giacomo Puccini (1893).[1] Film adaptations followed as soon as the medium was invented, beginning with a 1908 silent film adaptation of Puccini's opera. Early adaptations were period films, set in the eighteenth century; later film adaptations translate the novel's story to a contemporary setting.

Stage adaptations

[edit]

The first theatrical adaptation of Manon Lescaut was in 1772.[1] This was a comedy titled The Virtuous Courtesan (French: La Courtisane vertueuse),[2] which ends with Manon surviving.[3] It attempted to mix a sensitive and emotional portrayal of the lovers with some humour,[2] but reviewers found it far inferior to the novel.[1] Relatively few of the early theatrical adaptations of Manon Lescaut have survived.[4] There were a few dramas in the eighteenth century and the Romantic period, followed by a larger number in the early twentieth century.[5] In 1913, five plays based on Manon Lescaut were scheduled in Paris theatres simultaneously, though the outbreak of World War I prevented them from all being staged.[6][7] Although ballets and operas of Manon Lescaut became popular,[8] only three theatrical dramas had even a modest success: The Virtuous Courtesan (1772), Manon Lescaut et le chevalier Desgrieux (1820), and Manon Lescaut (1851).[2] All three include some incidental music, and the 1820 melodrama is also accompanied by a ballet.[8] These adaptations dramatize the narrative in similar ways.[9] Several scenes are consistently included: Manon attending des Grieux's final seminary examination to reunite after his father has separated them; Manon rejecting an Italian prince who seeks her out as a courtesan; and des Grieux desperately burying Manon in Louisiana.[9]

Black and white photograph of a woman in luxurious eighteenth-century garb, gazing pleadingly above her
Sibyl Sanderson as Manon for an 1891 production of Jules Massenet's Manon (1884)
Another black and white photograph of a woman in luxurious eighteenth-century garb, gazing pleadingly above her
Maria Farneti as Manon for a 1900 production of Giacomo Puccini's Manon Lescaut (1893)

The literary historian Jean Sgard argues that operatic adaptations came late in the legacy of the novel because the story's mixture of genres was incompatible with the eighteenth century's dominant genre of serious opera, as characterized by Handel and Rameau.[10] The first operatic adaptation in 1836 was not a success.[10] An important change in operatic precedent came after Giuseppe Verdi's highly successful 1853 opera, La traviata ("The Fallen Woman").[11] La traviata is based on the play and novel The Lady of the Camellias by Alexandre Dumas fils, which are themselves heavily inspired by Manon Lescaut.[12] After 1853, six operas based on Manon Lescaut were written.[13] These operas vary widely in how they adapt the story: it is divided into differing numbers of sections (from three to seven acts), and adaptations exist in the different operatic genres of comic opera, opera, and lyric drama.[13] One opera has Manon miraculously revive after her death scene in Louisiana;[14] another removes the entire American episode and has her die in France.[15] The most renowned adaptations of Manon Lescaut are the operas by Daniel Auber (1856), Jules Massenet (1884), and Giacomo Puccini (1893).[1]

In the theatrical and operatic adaptations, Manon's three lovers are combined into just one character.[16] Theatrical adaptations simplify the plot to one instance of infidelity, a reconciliation, and then the final tragedy,[9] and operatic adaptations forgo the novel's long decline to dramatically juxtapose young love and tragic death.[17] The literary scholar Jean Sgard argues that by reducing the complexity of the narrative, the theatrical adaptations present the lovers as being disproportionately punished for a single mistake, rather than capturing the novel's feeling of a gradual descent into immorality.[9] He further argues that operatic adaptations are forced to focus on a one-note characterization of Manon,[18][note 1] and each opera's evaluation of her moral character is expressed in its depiction of her death.[19]

List of dramas, operas and ballets

[edit]

Film adaptations

[edit]
Black and white photograph. Manon, seated, gives the camera a direct and provocative look; des Grieux, eyes closed, leans in as if smelling her hair. Both wear eighteenth-century garb.
Dolores Costello as Manon and John Barrymore as des Grieux in When a Man Loves (1927)

Manon Lescaut was adapted several times after the invention of film.[32] Six silent films were made, of which nearly all are lost due to the degradation of nitrate film.[33] The first was a 1908 adaptation of Puccini's opera, which used a device called a "cinemofono" to synchronize the film with a music recording.[34] It remained in theaters for a month.[35] The only silent films to survive are some footage from a 1926 film by Arthur Robison, and the 1927 Hollywood adaptation When a Man Loves.[33] According to the literary historian Alan J. Singerman, several early films alter the plot to present Manon as an innocent victim who will be more sympathetic to film audiences than an "amoral and guilty" figure motivated by a "love of luxury and pleasure".[36] He says: "unlike readers of the novel, theater and cinema audiences do not have the intervention of a sympathetic narrator like Des Grieux to elicit their indulgence toward the dubious behavior of Prévost's Manon."[note 16]

Early adaptations were period films, set in the eighteenth century;[32] later film adaptations translate the novel's story to a contemporary setting.[38] The 1949 film Manon by Henri-Georges Clouzot depicts des Grieux as a member of the French Resistance and Manon as a Nazi collaborator; he and Manon enter the black market and eventually stowaway to Palestine with a group of Jewish refugees.[39][22] In Manon 70 by Jean Aurel, released in 1968 and set in the near-future of 1970, des Grieux is a globetrotting radio journalist who tags along with Manon's sugar baby lifestyle;[40] instead of ending with Manon's tragic death, this film concludes with both Manon and des Grieux hitchhiking.[39] A pair of television miniseries directed by Jean-Xavier de Lestrade in 2014 and 2017 presents Manon as a contemporary young woman in a youth detention center[note 17] who is failed by social systems and lives precariously.[38]

List of films

[edit]

Notes

[edit]
  1. ^ Sgard says: "With opera, you have to choose: Manon will be a bird caught in a trap (Auber), a deviant woman redeeming herself (Verdi), a weak woman searching for herself (Massenet), a free and rebellious woman (Puccini), a being in perdition (Henze)" (French: "Avec l'opéra, il faut choisir: Manon sera donc un oiseau pris au piège (Auber), une dévoyée se rachète (Verdi), une faible femme qui se cherche elle-même (Massenet), une femme libre et révoltée (Puccini), un être en perdition (Henze)")[18]
  2. ^ French: La Courtisane vertueuse
  3. ^ In four acts. This play was first published in London and Paris in 1772, and reprinted with the title Manon Lescaut ou la courtisane vertueuse in 1774, but not performed until 1782.[2]
  4. ^ Music by Fromental Halevy. First performed at the Paris Opera on 3 May 1830.[23]
  5. ^ Libretto by Bunn. First performed at Drury Lane on May 27, 1836, sung by Malibran.[10] Adds a happy ending, in which Manon revives in Louisiana.[14]
  6. ^ Music by Vincenzo Bellini. First staged at Teatro Alla Scalla. Ends with Manon marrying Des Grieux rather than dying.[22]
  7. ^ Music by Matthias Trebinger[22]
  8. ^ Comic opera in three acts. Libretto by Eugène Scribe. First performed at the Opéra-Comique.[10]
  9. ^ Comic opera in five acts. Libretto by Henri Meilhac and Philippe Gilles. First performed at the Opéra-Comique on January 19, 1884.[10]
  10. ^ German: Manon Lescaut oder Schloss de Lorme
  11. ^ Lyric drama in four acts. Libretto by L. Illica, G. Giacosa. M. Praga, R. Leoncavallo, and G. Ricordi. First performed in Turin, February 1, 1893.[13]
  12. ^ The play was first written around 1908. Performances were planned in 1912, 1913, and 1914, but it was not staged until 1924.[7][6][28]
  13. ^ First performed at the D40 theatre, a radical theatre in Prague[22]
  14. ^ Lyric drama in seven acts. Libretto by Greta Wiel. First performed in Hanover on February 17, 1952.[13]
  15. ^ The music by Massenet is not from Massenet's Manon Lescaut, but rather is a selection of his other pieces arranged by Leighton Lucas and Hilda Gaunt.[30]
  16. ^ French: à l'encontre des lecteurs du roman, le public du théâtre et du cinéma n'a pas l'intervention d'un narrateur complaisant comme Des Grieux pour susciter leur indulgence à l'égard du comportement douteux de la Manon de Prévost.[37]
  17. ^ More specifically, a centre éducatif fermé [fr], a French alternative for prison for minors[39]
  18. ^ Duration of 200 meters[35]
  19. ^ The original was likely more than 90 minutes; the surviving copy is 28 minutes of a later version with French subtitles[42]
  20. ^ Duration of 110 minutes; Vitaphone musical score of Verdi[44]
  21. ^ Set in the Second French Empire[46]

References

[edit]

Citations

[edit]
  1. ^ a b c d Sgard 1995, p. 187.
  2. ^ a b c d e Sgard 1995, p. 178.
  3. ^ Leichman 2017, pp. 102.
  4. ^ Sgard 1995, p. 177.
  5. ^ Sgard 1995, pp. 177–8.
  6. ^ a b c "Five 'Manon" Plays to be Seen in Paris; Three of Them Taken by New York Managers for Presentation Here". The New York Times. 1913-09-28. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2025-09-27.
  7. ^ a b c "Paris, Where Woman Reigns". The Triad. Vol. 10, no. 4. 1925-02-02.
  8. ^ a b Sgard 1995, p. 186.
  9. ^ a b c d Sgard 1995, p. 185.
  10. ^ a b c d e f g h i Sgard 1995, p. 191.
  11. ^ Sgard 1995, pp. 189, 207.
  12. ^ Sgard 1995, p. 189.
  13. ^ a b c d e f g Sgard 1995, p. 192.
  14. ^ a b Giroud 2014, p. 242.
  15. ^ Giroud 2014, p. 254.
  16. ^ Sgard 1995, pp. 185, 193.
  17. ^ Sgard 1995, p. 193.
  18. ^ a b Sgard 1995, p. 194.
  19. ^ Sgard 1995, pp. 207–8.
  20. ^ Giroud 2014, p. 265.
  21. ^ Sgard 1995, p. 180.
  22. ^ a b c d e f g h i "The Story of Manon – in Literature, Film and Pop". English National Ballet. 2018-07-13. Archived from the original on 2025-08-24. Retrieved 2025-02-17.
  23. ^ Giroud 2014, pp. 242–243.
  24. ^ Giroud 2014, pp. 244, 266.
  25. ^ Giroud 2014, p. 252.
  26. ^ Giroud 2014, p. 267.
  27. ^ "Répertoire". Odéon-Théâtre de l'Europe. Archived from the original on 2025-06-24. Retrieved 2025-09-27.
  28. ^ ""Manon Lescaut." A Dramatised Version". The Daily Telegraph. November 5, 1924. p. 6. Retrieved 2025-09-27.
  29. ^ Balanchine & Mason 1989, p. 247.
  30. ^ Balanchine & Mason 1989, p. 251-252.
  31. ^ "Performance Info: 'Manon'". Takarazuka Revue. Archived from the original on 2025-02-16. Retrieved 2025-02-16.
  32. ^ a b c Romney, Jonathan (2019-06-20). "Manon on screen". Opera Holland Park. Archived from the original on 2024-05-22. Retrieved 2025-02-17.
  33. ^ a b c Singerman 2000, p. 369-370.
  34. ^ a b Adams 2023, p. 100.
  35. ^ a b c d e Singerman 2000, p. 369.
  36. ^ Singerman 2000, p. 370-371, 374, 382.
  37. ^ a b Singerman 2000, p. 370.
  38. ^ a b Wyngaard 2019, pp. 467–9.
  39. ^ a b c d e f g Wyngaard 2019, p. 467.
  40. ^ Leichman 2017, pp. 97.
  41. ^ Manon Lescaut (1926). 2014-06-12. Archived from the original on 2023-03-30. Retrieved 2025-02-17.
  42. ^ Singerman 2000, pp. 370–371.
  43. ^ "When a Man Loves". AFI Catalog. Archived from the original on 2025-01-19. Retrieved 2025-02-17.
  44. ^ Singerman 2000, p. 372.
  45. ^ Klossner 2002, p. 242.
  46. ^ a b Singerman 2000, pp. 374–375.
  47. ^ Singerman 2000, p. 375.
  48. ^ "Les Amours de Manon Lescaut de Mario Costa (1955)". Unifrance. Archived from the original on 2025-03-18. Retrieved 2025-02-17.
  49. ^ a b Singerman 2000, p. 379.
  50. ^ Leichman 2017, pp. 93, 97.
  51. ^ "Manon". Festival des 3 Continents. Archived from the original on 2025-04-20. Retrieved 2025-02-17.
  52. ^ "Manon Lescaut". Rotten Tomatoes. Archived from the original on 2025-08-25. Retrieved 2025-02-17.

Works cited

[edit]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Adaptations_of_Manon_Lescaut&oldid=1313871031"